• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Canada
  • United Kingdom
  • Subscribe
  • facebook
  • instagram
  • RSS
  • RSMUS.com

The Real Economy Blog

Search

  • Economics
  • Technology
  • Consumer
  • Industrials
  • Finance
  • Real Estate
  • Health Care
  • Life Sciences
Home > Financial Services > A Labor Department rule puts spotlight on ESG in retirement plans

A Labor Department rule puts spotlight on ESG in retirement plans

Nov. 6, 2020 by Anthony DeCandido

  • email
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin

As investors increasingly focus on environmental, social and governance issues in the corporate sector, an important question remains: What is the true purpose of ESG? Is it to drive returns, or to simultaneously do right by society?

Along with that question has come concern over fiduciary responsibility. Do investors hold up their legal and ethical relationship of trust by creating the greatest level of profit, or do nonfinancial outcomes matter, too?

The Labor Department affirmed that managers of retirement plans hold a fiduciary duty to evaluate investments.

The Labor Department has tried to address those questions by issuing a recent rule.

On Oct. 30, the Labor Department released a rule that modifies certain provisions of the investment duties regulation, which is applicable to plans in the Employee Retirement Income Security Act.

In the rule, the Labor Department affirms that managers of retirement plans hold a fiduciary duty to evaluate investments based on appropriate perspectives consistent with the plan’s objectives.

The rule holds that funds in retirement plans select risk-and-returns on investments over ESG or other nonfinancial outcomes. This is not to say that ESG strategies must be excluded from investing in retirement plans, but it does imply that a strong correlation be substantiated when selecting ESG strategies to drive profits.

The rule includes new documentation requirements in instances when a fiduciary uses nonfinancial factors in choosing investments. The requirements are intended to prevent fiduciaries from making investment decisions based on nonfinancial results without considering how they could affect returns.

Middle market reaction

Despite this rule, many middle market firms argue that the proposal is overly prescriptive and prioritizes financial outcomes over the behavior itself. After all, they argue, many investments with the right ESG objectives drive the returns that would be expected of a fiduciary. Does it have to be one and not the other?

Further, there is overwhelming empirical evidence showing that organizations that implement ESG practices enhance long-term corporate financial performance. A company’s ESG information is transmitted through its systemic risk profile (lower cost of capital and higher valuations) and its idiosyncratic risk profile (higher profitability and lower tail risk).

An analysis of more than 2,000 empirical studies found that 90% of these studies found a non-negative relationship between ESG practices and corporate financial performance, and a large majority found a positive relationship.

This has become particularly true in RSM’s proprietary middle market research, which shows that companies are committed – often with formalized plans – to serve a variety of stakeholder interests. Of those companies familiar with ESG, 79% of middle market organizations said they use ESG criteria to evaluate their own performance, and 74% use ESG to evaluate the performance of other organizations.

The rule is subject to a period of public comment and can potentially be reversed. But it is set to become effective at the end of the year.

 

  • email
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin

Related posts

  • graphic of industrial products
    Manufacturers face tight labor, rising wages in 2019

    Forecasts call for manufacturing growth to increase faster than the general economy in coming years, with production estimated to rise 2.8 percent from 2018 to 2021, according to the Manufacturers Alliance for Productivity and Innovation Foundation (MAPI). This…

  • Public scrutiny over ESG holdings will cause universal reporting change

    As environmental, social and governance investing continues to grow in popularity, investors need to carefully evaluate how their holdings will be viewed by the public. Asset managers must balance their desire to promote ESG consciousness with their fiduciary…

  • How ESG is affecting the real estate and construction industries

    As public pressure builds for industries to adhere to environmental, social and governance standards, real estate and construction are no exception.

Filed Under: Financial Services Tagged With: asset management, ESG, Labor Department, retirement plans

About Anthony DeCandido

@adecandido1

Anthony is a Partner at RSM US LLP with over thirteen years of experience at the firm. He serves as the Connecticut Financial Services Leader and his client responsibilities includes private equity funds, including those with multiple co-investment vehicle arrangements, hedge funds, fund-of-funds, real estate investment companies and asset lending businesses.

In January 2018, Anthony was selected as a senior analyst in RSM’s cutting edge Industry Eminence Program, which positions its senior analysts to understand, forecast and communicate economic, business and technology trends shaping the industries RSM serves. These senior analysts advise clients on conditions impacting middle market leaders. Anthony’s focus is on the financial services industry.

Primary Sidebar

Other Regions

  • Canada
  • United Kingdom

Categories

  • Economics
  • Technology
  • Consumer Products
  • Industrials
  • Financial Services
  • Real Estate
  • Health Care
  • Life Sciences

Recent Finance articles

Low interest rates offer private equity firms a rare opportunity to invest

Feb. 25, 2021

CHART OF THE DAY: ESG comes to financial services

Feb. 25, 2021

Private equity and venture capital stay resilient in the EU and UK

Feb. 17, 2021

RSMUS.com links

The Real Economy

Middle Market Business Index

MMBI Special Reports

Footer

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • RSS

About The Real Economy Blog

The Real Economy Blog from RSM US LLP was developed to provide timely economic insights about the middle market economy. It is offered as a complement to RSM’s macroeconomic thought leadership, including The Real Economy monthly publication and the proprietary RSM US Middle Market Business Index (MMBI).

© 2021 RSMUS.com | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy

The Real Economy Blog
  • Economics
  • Technology
  • Consumer
  • Industrials
  • Finance
  • Real Estate
  • Health Care
  • Life Sciences