• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Canada
  • United Kingdom
  • Subscribe
  • facebook
  • instagram
  • RSS
  • RSMUS.com

The Real Economy Blog

Search

  • Economics
  • Technology
  • Consumer
  • Industrials
  • Finance
  • Real Estate
  • Health Care
  • Life Sciences
Home > Real Estate > Real estate investors seen as primary funding source for “the caring economy” plan

Real estate investors seen as primary funding source for “the caring economy” plan

Jul. 23, 2020 by Troy Merkel

  • email
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin

It is unlikely that 1031 exchanges will be a serious funding source for “the caring economy” plan.

Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden on Tuesday unveiled a 10-year, $775-billion plan to support what he deemed “the caring economy,” which is comprised of jobs that provide care for children and the elderly. In order to finance this proposal, Biden is looking to the real estate investment community.

Like most proposals announced on the campaign trail, this plan has garnered a lot of headlines while offering few details; meanwhile, American voters are left trying to fill in the blanks, leading to assumptions about the plan’s intentions.

Here’s what we do know:

  • Like-kind exchanges, commonly called 1031 exchanges, are specifically being targeted
  • Real estate investors with incomes of more than $400,000 will be a focus

1031 exchanges

Under section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code, 1031 exchanges are tax-motivated transactions that allow investors to sell real estate holdings for a profit and avoid paying taxes on gains, as long as those proceeds are invested into another “like-kind” of real estate asset. This tax provision is often used by high-net-worth investors and family offices as a tax mitigation and planning strategy. The survival of 1031 exchanges was assured under the Tax Reform and Jobs Act.

It is unlikely that 1031 exchanges will be a serious funding source for “the caring economy” plan. According to Congress’s Joint Committee on Taxation, the use of 1031 exchanges is projected to result in only $51 billion in tax savings from 2019-2023. Even if that number were to triple over a 10-year period, the proposed plan would still fall $625 billion short in funding.

Furthermore, when we focus on the middle market real estate investment community, the use of 1031 exchanges is primarily a tax strategy for a niche market of smaller investors; more than 60% of 1031 exchanges involve properties worth less than $1 million, according to 1031taxreform.com.

High earners and long-term capital gains

Shifting our focus to the funding that could be provided by real estate investors with incomes more than $400,000, we start to get a clearer picture of how the $775 billion plan will be financed. In order to dive below the headlines of recent days, we need to look at Biden’s overall tax proposal announced earlier this year.

The Biden campaign previously outlined tax reforms that would target all individuals, not just real estate professionals, who make more than $400,000 annually with the following:

  • Providing 12.4% old-age, survivors and disability insurance
  • Reverting the top end tax rate back to 39.6% from 37%
  • Taxing long-term gains and qualified dividends at the ordinary tax rate, not a flat 20%
  • Limiting itemized deductions for high-earning individuals
  • Phasing out qualified business income deductions (section 199A)

These changes, in particular increased taxes of long-term capital gains, will have a substantial impact on the real estate investment community. While large, tax-exempt real estate investors such as pension funds will shrug at this change, for-profit real estate investors have come to rely on this tax benefit to produce yields that have inflated real estate values, helping to drive profits for all real estate investors.

The long-term capital gains tax policies will have broad implications, with traditional equities investors also seeing a rise in their taxes. Steeper taxes on high-earning individuals, including this capital gains tax, are estimated to raise $1.2 trillion over 10 years, according to taxfoundation.org, and would be able to foot the estimated $775 billion bill that comes with the “caring economy” plan.

The takeaway

In summary, the tax plan outlined by the Biden campaign in April will have a significant impact on real estate and non-real estate investors. Changes to the 1031 exchange rules will impact smaller investors, but not the broader institutional investment community. However, the changes in capital gains rules will reduce after-tax returns for a broad array of real estate investors, which would translate to a decrease in valuations of long-term hold assets such as real estate.

The combined impact of these changes would likely reduce property turnover, which is a driver for renovations and economic growth through the creation of construction jobs and the consumption of building materials. When owners are not incentivized to sell, real estate become stale and a driver of community reinvestment is taken off the table.

  • email
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin

Related posts

  • Real estate investors hope for the best, prepare for the worst—KAYO conference

    "Economic cycles and real estate cycles don’t die of old age," writes Laura Dietzel, RSM senior real estate analyst. "Most of the top industry investors, executives and advisors at the (Kayo) conference agreed that the industry currently finds…

  • real estate graphic
    Demographics, policy to drive 2019 real estate investment

    Fundamentals in the real estate market continue to be strong; however, at this late stage in the business cycle, investors need to be cautious as they venture into the development of more third-tier markets. Changes in demographics will…

  • Real estate dry powder hits record levels amid stock market volatility, rising property values

    Real-estate focused private equity funds are sitting on record amounts of dry powder amid stock market volatility and rising property values. That amount reached $345.2 billion in the United States through August 2019, the highest level since research…

Filed Under: Real Estate Tagged With: 1031 exchanges, Biden, Real estate, Troy Merkel

About Troy Merkel

@troymerkel

Troy Merkel is a Partner and Real Estate Senior Analyst at RSM. He has 15 years of experience in audit and consulting, with a particular emphasis in real estate and financial services reporting, in accordance with US GAAP, IFRS, NCREIF PREA Reporting Standards and income tax basis. He is also an expert in accounting for asset acquisitions and complex leases and specializes in various tax-advantageous, in particular Opportunity Zones and government subsidized deal structures.

In 2018, Troy was selected as a senior analyst in RSM’s cutting edge Industry Eminence Program, which positions its senior analysts to understand, forecast and communicate economic, business and technology trends shaping the industries RSM serves. These senior analysts advise clients on conditions impacting middle market leaders. Troy’s focus is on the real estate industry.

Primary Sidebar

Other Regions

  • Canada
  • United Kingdom

Categories

  • Economics
  • Technology
  • Consumer Products
  • Industrials
  • Financial Services
  • Real Estate
  • Health Care
  • Life Sciences

Recent Real Estate articles

CHART OF THE DAY: Housing activity continues to surge

Jan. 21, 2021

CHART OF THE DAY: Residential construction spending remains robust

Jan. 6, 2021

Traditional retail’s loss has been industrial’s gain

Dec. 22, 2020

RSMUS.com links

The Real Economy

Middle Market Business Index

MMBI Special Reports

Footer

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • RSS

About The Real Economy Blog

The Real Economy Blog from RSM US LLP was developed to provide timely economic insights about the middle market economy. It is offered as a complement to RSM’s macroeconomic thought leadership, including The Real Economy monthly publication and the proprietary RSM US Middle Market Business Index (MMBI).

© 2021 RSMUS.com | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy

The Real Economy Blog
  • Economics
  • Technology
  • Consumer
  • Industrials
  • Finance
  • Real Estate
  • Health Care
  • Life Sciences