By just about any measure, the homebuilding industry in the United States is stagnant. Housing starts in October increased by an anemic 1.309 million at an annualized pace.
Both the under construction and completions data advanced at a 1.272 million annualized pace while permits slowed to 1.295 million.
Any of these measures is far below what is needed to maintain an equilibrium between supply and demand—about 1.5 million new homes a year.
Get Joe Brusuelas’s Market Minute commentary every morning. Subscribe now.
And the market is about to get worse. The Federal Reserve is all but certain to raise the federal funds rate by 25 basis points at its December meeting, with the market pricing in a 72% probability of a January hike and a 68% chance of a March increase.
Both federal funds futures and overnight index swaps indicate that the Fed will raise its policy rate three times between now and the end of next year.
In many respects, residential investment is a casualty of the sustained increase in inflation, the Federal Reserve’s less accommodative monetary policy, and rising mortgage rates.
Mortgage rates have soared to over 7%. Home prices and rents are out of reach for people just starting out. And the supply of new homes has been dropping for the past five years.
All of this is occurring at a time when the combination of an increase in government borrowing and a rising allocation of private capital into the AI build-out have siphoned capital away from areas like homebuilding.
Residential investment’s contribution to gross domestic product, which reached a 6% share of GDP before the 2008 housing market collapse, had barely recovered before falling again to 3% this year.
Instead, nonresidential investment is accelerating. Its GDP output has moved from a 10.3% share in 2009 to 16.7% in the third quarter of this year, with the latest surge coinciding with the AI build-out.
The diminished role of housing is evident in the drop in sentiment among homebuilders as surveyed by the National Association of Home Builders. Their diffusion index has dropped sharply, to 25 on a scale of zero to 100
The drop in sentiment reflects the decline in housing starts after its decade-long recovery from the 2008 crash. Since 2022, total housing starts, which include both single-family and multi-family structures, have been dropping on a 12-month average basis.
In addition, since the pandemic, interest rates have soared along with building costs as the labor supply has tightened under restrictive immigration policies. The result is an increasing cost of construction and rising risk for homebuilders.
That forms a negative feedback loop of increased costs. dampening the potential supply of housing stock while limiting the supply of customers.
The takeaway
The stagnant supply of housing implies an increase in home prices and rents, making it difficult for households to begin benefiting from what would be their most significant investment.
Our estimate on residential investment for next year implies a soggy 1.325 million at an annualized pace.
The divergence in residential and nonresidential investment implies expectations of a greater return in the latter. That suggests that state and local public policymakers should be increasing rather than limiting the growth of their housing stock.
Those who intend to do something about affordability within the housing sector should understand that it is far easier said than done amid strong above-trend growth, elevated inflation and long-term rates that may increase as well.




